Posted on by Omair Raza

Elle Woods: On the Other Side of Oppression

As a pro-feminist queer who whole-heartedly endorses radical feminism, I took myself to task for admiring the ‘post-feminist’ film Legally Blonde when I saw it the other day. Is Elle Woods, a bubbly ultra-pink sorority girl who survives the rigors of Harvard Law while being true to herself, an icon of liberation? Or is she just a pop-culture fantasy of a woman who ‘has it all’ – unrealistic, not to mention, anti-feminist, in how she represents an ideal of empowerment that ultimately only caters to male desire?

Both, I would argue. But let’s first bring those readers up to speed who don’t know the radical from the postmodern in their feminism: while the former position holds that femininity and masculinity are effects of structural oppression and privilege respectively, the latter, valorizing agency over structure, recognizes the plurality of ways in which we can be feminine or masculine, none belonging exclusively on one side of any dichotomy that we can think of. While radfems think of femininity as a handicap to self-actualization, post-feminists do not want to fix the meaning of femininity, positing it instead as an unstable, shifting construct.

Of course it’s difficult to endorse Elle Woods as some ground-breaking icon of anti-establishmentarian feminist ideals given that alpha-femmes like her have always been the favorites of the American entertainment industry. Only now, the trope of feminine-charms comes combined with the trope of empowerment, so much the worse for how that is an even more unattainable ideal for women than traditional femininity. So, nothing liberating about that. But central to the plot is Elle’s struggle as a lawyer who won’t divest herself of her identity, even though she is competing at a game whose rules have been defined by men. She is no Lady Macbeth who needs spirits to ‘unsex’ her and ‘make thick [her] blood’. The male Professor Callahan who hires her for an internship on an actual courtroom case will not only have to accept her pink, scented resume, but also deal with her rejection of his ‘reason’ which required her to reveal the defendant’s alibi against their wishes. Values of sympathy and sisterhood trumped the courtroom reason, and she won the case without having to resort to the alibi which would have destroyed the defendant’s professional life.

And this, dear cynic, is where I see the potential of liberation in this narrative: the liberation of femininity from associations of dependence and weakness.

The bit of theory I shared above can make sense now. While historically, femininity might have been a tool of oppression in patriarchal culture, it is possible to envision a world beyond oppression, and by extension, one where femininity is not a handicap. When oppression is out, what’s left behind is people’s sense of selves. And isn’t it progressive to encourage people to build an authentic sense of self on their own terms free from undue social pressures? Wasn’t this the principle at the heart of all twentieth-century social movements? So why not extend it to a feminine sense of self? If you’re effeminate, you’re dismissed as frivolous, and your expressiveness and grace are called displays of ‘weakness’ and ‘excessive refinement’. Now how objective is that judgment? And don’t get me wrong: there is no fighting oppression by dolling oneself up and playing nice all the time if that’s all you do. Women lack the agency to be assertive, and changing that should be a goal for feminism to work for. But can’t one be assertive while wearing a lipstick? Obviously it’s more than just about self-presentation: a feminine sense of self can engender an ethos that affirms community, embraces difference, celebrates personal affection and sensitizes rational judgment through emotion.

Lest I be accused of ‘essentialism’, I want to make it clear that these values are ‘feminine’ only in the sense that they are labeled as signs of ’emasculation’ or ‘effeminacy’ in a culture that ennobles the ethos of control and repression of emotion, and privileges competition over cooperation. It’s also telling how the words ‘effeminate’ and ’emasculate’ are used to denote a lack of virility, or manly vigor, while the word for womanly vigor, ‘muliebrity’ is much too obscure, and there is none to denote it’s lack. Such labeling is also used more for gender-nonconforming men. ‘Effeminate’ and ’emasculated’ are almost never used for those born and raised as women: it is reserved for males who shun ideals of virility. So there is a systematic devaluation of femininity in which not only women, but also ‘the sissies’, ‘the fags’ and the ‘queens’, not to mention transsexuals, become degraded. Noteworthy among the various ways in which this plays out is the medicalization of femininity: because of the stereotype of woman-as-week, doctors are twice as likely to be diagnose women with depression, even when they have similar scores on standardized measures of depression or present with identical symptoms.1 Similarly, the referral rates of ‘Gender Identity Disorder’ (now called ‘Gender Incongruence’) have a sex-ratio of 6.6:1 of boys to girls – in other words, if there’s a mismatch between your assigned gender role and your sense of self, you’re more easily pathologized if you identify as feminine.2

For this queer guy, ‘masculine privilege’, in the final analysis, is just a prerogative to be selfish and sloppy. Radical feminism might be able to win that prerogative for women, but those of us who reject virility, irrespective of our assigned genders, let us aim higher: for a different world in which, no longer imbued with a sense of shame and lack, femininity can become an ideal for self-realization, beyond the matrix of oppression and privilege.

 

______

1. Callahan, E.J. et al. (1997). “Depression in primary care: patient factors that influence recognition.” Family Medicine, 29: 172-176.

2. Kenneth et al. (1997). “Sex Differences in Referral Rates of Children with Gender Identity Disorder.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 25/3: 217-227.

 

 


363 Replies to “Elle Woods: On the Other Side of Oppression”

  1. I found your article most edifying. I remember when first I saw Legally Blonde in the cinema in late 2001, and then the sequel on video. Yes, she can be both. I was reading also about when “we’re going to have the generation who has it all”.
    Thank you.

    Reply

  2. Its nice to see what you have to say about the ’emasculate’ and ‘sissy’ men.I remember coming across a discussion on the then youth iconic social networking website,Orkut,where a homosexual man was not happy with the Pride Parade in India,right after the Delhi High Court struck down article 377. He objected to effeminate homosexuals and drag queens. At that time I might have thought ‘perhaps’ (notice I said Perhaps) he might be right.At first we are giving them our image as sissies and then complaining the media portrayal of ourselves as sissies and effeminate.

    But every time I reason out I tend to accept our sissy and effeminate brothers and masculine sisters more and more.They are the best of our community.Of course they are not the ‘only’ face of our Queer community,but also the masculine men and feminine women,whom we ought to portray equally.But the effeminate men and masculine women do much more than just be sissy or butch,respectively.They DEFY the socially constructed gender roles.That of course again turns around as another win for our feminist sisters.But of all the people women shock me when they disregard homosexuality as sin/unnatural etc. Not all,and generally women have been way way way more tolerant than men.But whenever I come across the openly homophobic ones,I am shocked,because these same women we support and their liberation too. However I have also noticed that all these women,in my experience, are also anti-feminism.They deem full knowledge of body as abominable and madonna,or even taking your heroine Elle, as hags and harlots serving themselves to men.

    But then again,have you ever wondered what would have happened if MEN would have been constantly subdued and oppressed as we today oppress and subdue women and if WOMEN would have been all powerful and declared male nudity and promiscuity as outrageous? Then would it have been outrageous of me to take of my shirt in public? And also,am ‘I’ or any other man,especially the brad pitts,not serving the fantasy of women? Do you really imagine only men get turned on by bikini babes and that women dont get turned by muscles? Then why not right and article against men taking their shirts off in public?

    If a man wear his underpants and dance around a pole,its fun and all that.But if a woman does that,she’s a hag and not a respectable woman? I find that strange.Where you say that Elle is serving the desires and fantasies of men,or something like that,I smell such an undertone.

    Reply

  189. I was suggested this website by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my problem. You are incredible! Thanks!

    Reply

  190. You really make it seem really easy with your presentation however I find this topic to be actually something that I feel I would by no means understand. It seems too complicated and very wide for me. I’m looking ahead on your subsequent put up, I’ll attempt to get the dangle of it!

    Reply

  292. The next time I learn a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I imply, I know it was my choice to learn, however I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you might repair should you werent too busy on the lookout for attention.

    Reply

  339. Looking for a simple way to free up disk space on your computer? Why not use the Disk Cleaner application? It makes your work easier by showing all that can be deleted on your disk drive.
    Fully featured application
    Disk Cleaner can be found in the Accessories folder, along with the usual collection of other programs. It features an appealing design and requires all standard software components to be present on your system; nothing suspicious is going on, since everything is safe and sound. https://cadowteti.weebly.com

    6add127376 ellmshan

    Reply

  340. However, its simplicity might not always be a good thing, as it might make it a little hard for novices to understand.

    Budget

    $75
    The yearly cost of this software.

    Dialogs

    Let’s dig into the interface to see more about the application.

    WinUI Dialogs

    GUI of.NET Dependency Walker
    This tool’s interface is fairly simple and simplistic.

    Installation https://sightribaral.weebly.com

    6add127376 colkirr

    Reply

  341. #Mountain Cave do you experience problems reading PDFs in Internet Explorer 9?This is a Safari extension that enables you to open PDF files directly in your browser. It works with Safari 6, Chrome and Firefox also.Download and install the extension.For Firefox users, just click on the ‘Bookmark’ button.For Chrome and Safari users, right-click a PDF file on your desktop and select ‘Open in Safari’.After you install this extension, you can tap the menu button https://nowoophisac.weebly.com

    6add127376 darwtay

    Reply

  344. Modules
    These modules provide the basic features to plan, design and manage your information project from 1 document to multiple document in your overall project.
    1. Document: Involves the design of a document from start to end whether you are creating a project plan, requiring presentation, project report or advisory document.
    2. Task: Involves the design of a task, budget for a task or a resource in your project.
    3. Issue: Involves how http://www.google.mv/url?q=https://raturkgabunk.weebly.com

    6add127376 walssala

    Reply

  345. Modules
    These modules provide the basic features to plan, design and manage your information project from 1 document to multiple document in your overall project.
    1. Document: Involves the design of a document from start to end whether you are creating a project plan, requiring presentation, project report or advisory document.
    2. Task: Involves the design of a task, budget for a task or a resource in your project.
    3. Issue: Involves how http://www.google.mv/url?q=https://raturkgabunk.weebly.com

    6add127376 walssala

    Reply

  346. The given features, thus, allow you to convert multiple files, of one single format or from different folders, in a short time. TTFA Images Converter can create editable multi-page PDFs. Furthermore, you may also select the size of the page, in order to produce a high-quality output.
    tTFA Images Converter includes a fast and simple user interface. The program allows users to select settings, input and output folder, as well as all other operations. http://cse.google.td/url?q=https://dinglaceca.weebly.com

    6add127376 janulatr

    Reply

  347. Samplexer retains a copy of your samples in its data folder until the host application shuts down. Although I have not used it myself, some hosts may save the data to disk during a save operation, resulting in fluttering notes on playback.
    There are 3 different types of audio output available: Via the VSTi, direct to DAW, and through the host application. The VSTi outputs may be selected by clicking the VSTi plugin’s button in the VSTi http://projectbee.com/redirect.php?url=https://neymisnoce.weebly.com

    6add127376 kaydar

    Reply

  348. Regenerate rules from XAP file

    You can use the regeneration rules of your Cross-platfrom Application Programming Interface (XAP) file. In some cases you need to flush cache for rules to be regenerated correctly. Keep in mind: you should run this command only for local rules, not for XmlJava classes.Truly the Funniest “Toxic” Ballet Shoes For The Modern Gal

    Bar the fact that these shoes have http://szikla.hu/redir?url=https://anattiri.weebly.com

    6add127376 jamyedo

    Reply

  349. The invention relates to metering apparatus that dispenses a liquid and, more particularly, to a patch calibration apparatus for patch dispensing systems that dispense thermal patches that are deposited during the calibration process.
    Medical personnel, such as urologists, often monitor internal body conditions of patients using medical devices that detect changes in temperature. The systems include a thermally treated patch that is applied directly to the skin of the patient in response to a change in temperature that is sensed by a thermocouple https://ekja.org/m/makeCookie.php?url=https://netfmarpusa.weebly.com

    6add127376 zyrfab

    Reply

  350. A simple application that allows you to integrate multiple cloud storage services without worrying about your downtime.
    Price, according to the developer: $6.32
    After Installing, switch off your computer a few times so it install all the required dependencies (there is no paid version yet).

    A magical app from two guys that made it, after absorbing a multitude of free apps form third party, and after finally developing and releasing its feature set too.
    As simple as that. https://unthertendlong.weebly.com

    6add127376 farjar

    Reply

  351. If you need an inexpensive yet stable and easy to use software package in order to organize events and appointments on your computer, then QuickMonth Calendar is the one to go for.

    KILLER ENTREPUIS is a science-fiction action-RPG set in a post-apocalyptic Earth not too distant from our time. You will have to survive against rogue soldiers, mutants, other menaces … and even find out who killed your father!
    To download KILLER ENTREPUIS https://meoveraloo.weebly.com

    6add127376 makgrow

    Reply

  352. Enjoy!

    Q:

    How can I lower latency and running time with this code?

    For one of my assignments, I have to write a C program that solves the halting problem, using the code that appears below. However, I am running into a significant problem with this program, which results in an extremely high running time. For anyone who doesn’t know: “If a computer program, if executed in theory, will always halt”, the program in not solvable. http://toolbarqueries.google.com.ng/url?sa=i&url=https://ninglongnalno.weebly.com

    6add127376 bertfior

    Reply

  353. Serveral Antivirus Software for Local Network | F-Secure

    Enables remote users to connect to the network. Provides additional security by monitoring data from the network and having the ability to quarantine data. Can create User/Group Properties for access control. Configurable option to allow/disallow outgoing connections from users. Supports Network Connection to another network/wired/wireless and can be used without restrictions.

    1. Manage the settings for backup and restore in and out http://psingenieure.de/url?q=https://unfreecmoirie.weebly.com

    6add127376 macrjony

    Reply

  354. Designed with efficiency and ease-of-use in mind, the software may save you from a potential disaster caused by having too much unused space taking up a lot of space in your hard drive. So, if you’re into getting the most out of your computer’s capacity without worrying as much about disk space becoming a problem, then i.Disk may be something you’d want to try. However, its desktop nature may not have been built for all operating systems, so https://britophordrag.weebly.com

    6add127376 berval

    Reply

  355. But the problem is that you will be required to wipe your smartphone / tablet when installing it because it uses so much space (unfortunately, I don’t have a Win 10 pc so I can’t check).
    Bottom line
    You can learn new words with Word of the Day MX Lite. However, it’s not very mature, as it doesn’t offer demo videos that could help you learn.

    The new Google Pixel 3 is getting reams of updates, additions, and indeed, https://www.nvlsp.org/?URL=https://britophordrag.weebly.com

    6add127376 berval

    Reply

  356. Excel spreadsheet to vCard conversion application

    A simple, lightweight conversion utility that is a must have for everyone who has, or is about to publish a vCard file. Other useful features include conversion to a variety of social profile formats. However, Excel to vCard Converter is not exactly user friendly. Extremely poor performance and a very old look make this utility hard to use.
    vCard converter tool

    vCard files are the standard global format for exchanging contacts data. https://propalopib.weebly.com

    6add127376 vyncfel

    Reply

  357. A wide scope of quality standards are demanded of all such systems and these are fulfilled by the comprehensive infrastructure provided by ILIAS.
    A progressive, flexible, flexible, and well-rounded e-learning system, dedicated to the usage that it supports.Q:

    Select count(*) where pk < x in more than one table

    I have a table of payments and a table of payments being refunded. For each payment I have the primary key and the time it http://www.2bbit.com/redir.php?url=https://ibimarcris.weebly.com

    6add127376 blannel

    Reply

  358. 3DMLW supports three types of annotations on 3D objects:
    – Long 2D or abbreviated 3D text,
    – Camera (view) orientation,
    – Scalar object properties (annotations).

    The specific features of 3DMLW are as follows:
    – Design Your Own (3DMLW) — How to build anything.
    – 3d Text Engine — Create textual content interactively.
    – Viewing https://matanbdure.weebly.com

    6add127376 ackearl

    Reply

  359. This is done automatically if any 1 of the settings is enabled in the Prefs.
    Version 1.2:
    Added function to ask an error message box if the file is not readable (eg, blackberry).
    Version 1.1:
    Added support for Multi-part info embedded within a message (for example, iPhone Safari)
    Version 1.0:
    Added warning if the email has no text or attachment.
    (Decode Shell Extension makes no assumptions about the size, http://thatlevelagain.ru/go.php?url=https://social.wepoc.io/upload/files/2022/05/4wJhdSH9xPqjZpuJBVsW_19_217d4521880d274138b20b7ab5461b01_file.pdf 05e1106874 dorrosb

    Reply

  360. Though it is lacking in speed and automatic video detection mode, we can still say that it works.
    And with the application’s low price, we do recommend the tool for anyone who keeps an eye on their favorite streaming video websites.
    Have you used the application to download your favorite YouTube videos? If so, we would love to hear your thoughts about it.
    We at techRax like to empower those who stay connected online and need to get more speed and efficiency from their devices. Our https://wozyzy.com/upload/files/2022/05/i8qsNETTzD9Lrz2NCq4r_19_277251a92f4184b37b976484d87655b4_file.pdf 05e1106874 ottital

    Reply

  361. The game is pretty simple and once you figure out your device, most likely like you immediately did when you connected it, you won’t have much of a problem in figuring out if your equipment works good or not. That said, if you’re already in doubt of your device being able to successfully be connected to the GPS Port Checker, it would sure be nice to be able to connect your gadget to a computer already knowing that it’s a hard problem for other apps to tackle. https://cse.google.sc/url?sa=i&url=https://socialspace.ams3.digitaloceanspaces.com/upload/files/2022/05/1bBqxhn6AGOoYtygsaNx_19_13ecdcfce1944f9280672f7344ffd60a_file.pdf 05e1106874 lausir

    Reply

  362. 0License.

    License

    Visifire is released under the GNU General Public License version 3.0.

    Visifire – Choose and combine several gauges at the same time.With several gauges simultaneously, Visifire fills requirements to efficiently collect data. Visifire is so flexible, you can make use of numerous different kind of gauges. 

    Visifire allows you to assign a range, a minimum level https://cse.google.co.im/url?q=https://wakelet.com/wake/7tv9HeEDa7w6XpIMMayci 8cee70152a yesgeo

    Reply

  363. 0License.

    License

    Visifire is released under the GNU General Public License version 3.0.

    Visifire – Choose and combine several gauges at the same time.With several gauges simultaneously, Visifire fills requirements to efficiently collect data. Visifire is so flexible, you can make use of numerous different kind of gauges. 

    Visifire allows you to assign a range, a minimum level https://cse.google.co.im/url?q=https://wakelet.com/wake/7tv9HeEDa7w6XpIMMayci 8cee70152a yesgeo

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.